::Native.Strength::

March 30, 2012

Adapt to Climate Change, Now

Mother Earth is in for a destructive ride into the future, according to the full report from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change released this week called “Managing the Risks of Extreme Events and Disasters to Advance Climate Change Adaptation,” or SREX for short. Tribal nations and Indigenous Peoples, who generate fewer greenhouse emissions than any other group, could be among communities hit the hardest.

After 220 scientists from 62 countries finalized the report in Uganda last fall, the IPCC published a 19-page Summary to give policy makers tools ahead of the COP18 in Qatar this November to shape adaptation strategies to extreme weather events. A three-page fact sheet makes the technical report even easier to digest.

And digest you should.

IPCC scientists give compelling evidence to confirm a connection between climate change and extremes such as heat waves, record high temperatures and, in many regions, heavy precipitation.

“Extreme weather events can be very destructive for Tribes, many of whom are already suffering from lack of resources to begin with,” says Dr. Garrit Voggesser, national director of the National Wildlife Federation Tribal Partnerships program, and author of the Facing the Storm report. Heat waves and droughts can exacerbate plant and wildlife mortality, heighten the risk of wildfires and habitat loss, and compromise tribal lands.”

The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) reports that an unprecedented 14 weather and climate disasters made 2011 a year for the record books. One of those disasters left much of the Crow Nation in southeastern Montana under water last May. Damages and costs have also increased in recent decades.

Voggesser says power disruptions from storms, long dry spells and heavy floods can be difficult to recover from, especially for people who live close to the land and have limited economic resources.

“One thing that we have learned from past extreme events, such as major floods, here in the Pacific Northwest is that even if there is a small chance of such an event occurring, the impact on our communities can be disastrous,” says Seattle-based NWF scientist and climate researcher Dr. Patty Glick. “This new IPCC report really underscores the importance of heeding precaution and being prepared, especially in anticipation of even greater risks in an era of climate change.”

In South Dakota, the Lakota face the wrath of even harsher winters. A report from Colorado State University says temperature and precipitation will intensify over the entire Great Plains area. A news report from the New York Times says Lake Superior, upon which the Great Lakes tribes depend for food resources, “is running a fever.” The Southwest faces increased drought and climate Dust Bowl conditions with serious health implications for its peoples. Sea levels on all coasts in the U.S. and North America are predicted to rise and in some cases the rise will be catastrophic. Permafrost melting under villages in Alaska is tumbling their inhabitants into the ocean.

The Swinomish Indian Tribe in Washington State, after seeing from an earth-based view the serious disruptions already taking place initiated a scientific study that resulted in their 2008 “Swinomish Climate Change Initiative,” making them the first tribal community to be adaptation-, mitigation-, and resilient-ready.

“The Indian Nations face profound challenges to their cultures, economies and livelihoods, because of climate change,” says Voggesser. “Yet tribal peoples possess valuable knowledge and practices of their ecosystems that are resilient and cost-effective methods to address climate change impacts, for the benefit of all peoples. This study is a clear call for the Administration, Congress, state and local governments, and all peoples, to support and join tribal efforts to stem climate change.”

Click here to view the embedded video.

Read more @ Indian Country Today Media Network.comLean Federal Budget Favors Business: Aboriginals - ICTMN.com.

August 9, 2011

American Indians Feel the Effects of Climate Change at Higer Rate Than Other Groups

Filed under: Environment,News Alerts — Tags: , — ICTMN Staff @ 12:31 am

According to a new study from the National Wildlife Federation, American Indians suffer more from climate change than other groups.

The report states that “The high dependence of tribes upon their lands and natural resources to sustain their economic, cultural and spiritual practices, the relatively poor state of their infrastructure and the great need for financial and technical resources to recover from such events all contribute to the disproportionate impact on tribes.”

American Indians and Alaska natives suffer from the effects of a warming planet because they depend more on natural resources, oceans and rivers, according to the report, “Facing the Storm: Indian Tribes, Climate-Induced Weather Extremes and the Future for Indian Country.”

“Extreme weather events can be very destructive for tribes, many of whom are already suffering from lack of resources to begin with,” said Amanda Staudt—a scientist at the National Wildlife Federation and a contributor to the report—to The New York Times.

Read more @ Indian Country Today Media Network.comAmerican Indians Feel the Effects of Climate Change at Higer Rate Than Other Groups - Indian Country Today Media Network.com.

June 30, 2011

American Indians Vital in Climate Change Discussions

On Sept. 13, 2007, I watched the UN General Assembly in New York vote for the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. It was nearly a three-decade-long campaign for some of the American Indians who helped steer its passage.

It was a victorious day giving credence to the maintenance of aboriginal lands and preservation of indigenous rights.

Now, American Indian leaders face another international campaign. This time they are appealing for a seat at the table to discuss climate change impacts on indigenous peoples. They struck out during the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change discussions in Cancun last December.

Indigenous Environmental Network organizers will discuss local-to-global concerns July 28-31 during the Protecting Mother Earth Gathering on the Fort Berthold Reservation in North Dakota. Panelists will address the following worldwide topics: UNDRIP, green economies, climate change, climate justice, REDD, carbon markets, World People’s Conference on Climate Change and the Rights of Mother Earth, globalization, and RIO+20.

Climate change poses a monumental problem for indigenous peoples who “are among the first to face the direct consequences of climate change, due to their dependence upon, and close relationship, with the environment and its resources,” according to a report by the UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Peoples. “Climate change exacerbates the difficulties already faced by indigenous communities including political and economic marginalization, loss of land and resources, human rights violations, discrimination and unemployment.”

I recently worked with Rose High Bear, an Alaskan Athabaskan, to help her tell the story of climate change and indigenous peoples through a series of radio programs. She’s seeking funding for her project. She told me her personal story in trying to find a suitable caribou hide to make a traditional dress. Many of the hides she comes across have bug-eaten holes, an increasing problem attributable to warmer weather and a proliferation of mosquitos in the Arctic.

High Bear decided to make her dresses with the holey hides. It was one way to create awareness about climate change and its effect on indigenous communities. She and other indigenous peoples need messengers of all sorts considering the invisibility of indigenous peoples. Consider: It took some 25 years to get UNDRIP passed. Even then, Canada, the United States, New Zealand and Australia – all with considerable aboriginal populations – initially refused to sign.

An environmental and science reporting colleague, Terri Hansen, attended the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change discussions in Cancun. She reported: “Though I’d been there to cover the involvement of Native Americans and Indigenous Peoples at the talks, missing from the U.S. delegation was a representative for the 565 federally recognized tribes in the U.S…The tribes have requested that the U.S. include a tribal leader on their climate delegation, yet there is no engagement by the U.S. with the tribes in these climate negotiations.”

She noted the lack of tribal representation as “a grave concern” for the National Tribal Environmental Council and the National Council of American Indians. Attorneys from the Institute of Tribal Environmental Professionals and NCAI made three requests to meet with the U.S. delegation in Cancun.

Bob Gruenig of ITEP said the door was shut on them. “The U.S. delegation didn’t even make an attempt to include a tribal perspective. It was a replay of Copenhagen. Tribes didn’t get that meeting, either.”

In June 2012, world leaders will discuss green economies and poverty eradication as a main theme during RIO+20, the UN Conference on Sustainable Development. American Indians should have more than one seat at the table given that tribes occupy 55 million acres of trust land in the United States.

“Climate change poses threats and dangers to the survival of indigenous communities worldwide, even though indigenous peoples contribute the least to greenhouse emissions,” reports the UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Peoples. “Indigenous peoples are vital to, and active in, the many ecosystems that inhabit their lands and territories and may therefore help enhance the resilience of these ecosystems. In addition, indigenous peoples interpret and react to the impacts of climate change in creative ways, drawing on traditional knowledge and other technologies to find solutions which may help society at large to cope with impending changes.

Read more @ Indian Country Today Media Network.comAmerican Indians Vital in Climate Change Discussions - Indian Country Today Media Network.com.

August 27, 2012

Arctic Ice Hits Record Summer Low, Not Done Melting; See Video of Newly Exposed Ocean

The covering of ice over the Arctic has dropped to lows not seen since a record-breaking 2007, the National Snow & Ice Data Center (NSIDC) reported on August 27.

As of August 26, 2012, the sea ice extent, as it’s known in scientific parlance, dropped to 1.58 million square miles. That’s 27,000 square miles less than the measurement taken on September 18, 2007, when it dropped to 1.61 million square miles.

“By itself it’s just a number, and occasionally records are going to get set,” said NSIDC scientist Walt Meier in a statement. “But in the context of what’s happened in the last several years and throughout the satellite record, it’s an indication that the Arctic sea ice cover is fundamentally changing.”

The change is an issue for two reasons. First, this low point is occurring earlier in the year than the 2007 record, and second, the ice has not stopped melting. The annual minimum, which is the turning point at which the ice starts re-forming as winter approaches and Earth’s axis tilts back toward its winter solstice position, usually comes in September. In other words, as LiveScience put it, “The melt season still has another two or three weeks to go.”

Last year’s low point came on September 9, 2011, according to Reuters. Moreover, last year’s melt began 10–14 days earlier than normal in areas such as northern Europe and Siberia, NSIDC lead scientist Ted Scambos told the news wire.

The 2007 record was 23 percent below the earlier record, which occurred in 2005. It also fell 39 percent below the long-term average between 1979, when satellite recordkeeping began, and 2000, Reuters said. However, there was a key difference between 2007 and now.

“The previous record, set in 2007, occurred because of near perfect summer weather for melting ice,” said NSIDC Director Mark Serreze in the statement. “Apart from one big storm in early August, weather patterns this year were unremarkable. The ice is so thin and weak now, it doesn’t matter how the winds blow.”

Scambos also noted that the ice melt appears to be speeding up this year rather than slowing down as it normally does in waning summer in the Northern Hemisphere.

“Everything about this points in the same direction: We’ve made the Earth warmer,” Scambos told Reuters.

Below, a University of Delaware scientist caught some of the melt on video, with commentary on what it used to look like.

More on the melting Arctic ice and its effect on Indigenous Peoples:

Arctic Ice Melting Faster than Expected

Alaskan Native Communities Facing Climate-Induced Relocation

Greenland Turns to Slush as NASA Watches

Greenland’s Petermann Glacier Sheds 46-Square-Mile Chunk Into Arctic Ocean

Seething Phytoplankton Rainforest Discovered Beneath Arctic Ocean Ice Worries Scientists

Melting Permafrost Could Release Greenhouse Gases: NYT

Click here to view the embedded video.

Read more @ Indian Country Today Media Network.comAmerican Indian Tribes Make Offer on Black Hills Sacred Site - ICTMN.com.

September 3, 2011

Brazil’s Indigenous Imbira People: The Earth, Life and Water are Life, Not Money

Click here to view the embedded video.

“We indigenous communities are saying, look at the sky, it’s changing, the sun is changing, the rain is changing,” says Davi Kopenawa Yanomami, president of CAFOD partner Hutukara Yanomami Association in this video uploaded by GreenCollegeOnline on August 28.

In the video Yanomami discusses the issues that are effecting the Imbira, one of Brazil’s Indigenous Peoples and others throughout the world—issues such as deforestation and climate change.

The video is part of the project “Timbira People: working to the land management” executed by the NGO Indigenist Working Centre.

Read more @ Indian Country Today Media Network.comBrazil’s Indigenous Imbira People: The Earth, Life and Water are Life, Not Money - Indian Country Today Media Network.com.

November 30, 2011

Canada Racks Up Fossil Awards in Durban as Rumors of Kyoto Withdrawal Swirl

As rumors swirled about Canada’s potential withdrawal from the Kyoto Protocol on greenhouse gas emissions, the nation continued its Fossil Award–winning sweep at the COP17 talks in Durban, South Africa, on November 30 as the Climate Action Network (CAN) handed out its daily dose of anti-kudos to countries that put pollution-causing development ahead of lives.

On opening day, November 29, the northern nation won both second and first place for Environmental Minister Peter Kent’s continued bashing of developing countries as well as his implication that Canada would likely not sign on for an extension of the accord on emissions targets signed in Kyoto, Japan, in 1997.

In an interview with the Canadian Press before leaving for Durban, Kent said that lesser-developed countries must stop “wielding the historical guilty card” in asking for less-stringent emissions targets just because industrial countries historically have created more greenhouse gas emissions than other nations.

Kent further fueled the fire by claiming that “from Canada’s point of view, Kyoto was the biggest mistake the previous Liberal government made,” referring to Canada’s signing of the Kyoto Protocol.

This as the World Meteorological Organization (WMO) in its annual report to the U.N. talks said that 2011 has been the warmest year on record as far as climate goes.

With debate still raging over the use of bituminous crude from the notorious oil sands of northern Alberta, Canada, it would seem that Kent is hardly one to talk. Even China, one of the alleged major emitters, called on Canada to set a better example vis a vis combatting climate change. A Canadian withdrawal from the Kyoto Protocol would hurt the international community’s attempts to mitigate climate change, the deputy head of the Chinese delegation to Durban told the Chinese news agency Xinhua. It would “definitely add to the obstacles in our negotiation,” he said.

At the same time, Archbishop Desmond Tutu and other prominent Africans took out an ad in the conference’s daily newsletter ECO with “A Message for Canada during the UN Climate Summit in Durban” that was essentially a petition urging Canada to set a better example on combatting climate change the way it had against Apartheid in the 1980s.

“Canada, you were once considered a leader on global issues like human rights and environmental protection,” the ad said. “Today you’re home to polluting tar sands oil, speeding the dangerous effects of climate change. For us in Africa, climate change is a life and death issue. By dramatically increasing Canada’s global warming pollution, tar sands mining and drilling makes the problem worse, and exposes millions of Africans to more devastating drought and famine today and in the years to come. It’s time to draw the line. We call on Canada to change course and be a leader in clean energy and to support international action to reduce global warming pollution.”

The U.S.’s decision over the Keystone XL pipeline has been postponed until after the 2012 presidential election, and Canada has indicated it will take its oil sands products to Asia if the U.S. does not allow the construction of a 1,700-mile-long pipeline from Alberta to the Gulf of Mexico. Meanwhile several First Nations are set to reiterate their major opposition to Enbridge’s proposed Northern Gateway pipeline in the wake of a report by the National Resources Defense Council, the sustainable-energy think tank the Pembina Institute, and the marine conservation group the Living Oceans Society saying that the pipeline would risk too much environmental damage to be feasible. Several First Nations of British Columbia will hold a press conference in Vancouver on December 1.

On the day that Kent’s attitude netted Canada’s two opening-day Fossil Awards, third place went to Britain—but only because of its efforts to bring Canada’s tar sands oil into Europe.

“This quotation from Canadian Environment Minister Peter Kent, doesn’t even require paraphrasing in typical fossil humour—it is sufficiently outrageous on its own,” CAN said in bestowing those first Fossils.

Click here to view the embedded video.

Read more @ Indian Country Today Media Network.comInupiat Community Sues Companies Over Ravages of Climate Change - ICTMN.com.

February 24, 2012

Could Drought Have Caused Mayan Downfall?

The Maya are often thought of as one of the most advanced civilizations in the Americas. Their breakthroughs in astronomy enabled them to predict where the moon and planets would be years into the future and they left behind impressive architecture and artwork. A new study may have solidified a cause for their decline.

Researchers have determined that drought was indeed a factor in the demise of the Mayan empire, which occupied what is now southern Mexico and northern Central America, from about 250 A.D. to 950 A.D.

But how much of a factor is still up in the air.

A study published in the February 24 issue of Science shows research over the last 10 years of climate proxy records. According to ScienceMag.org, that means looking at lake and coastal sediments to detect rainfall levels.

Professor Martín Medina-Elizalde, of the Yucatan Center for Scientific Research in Mexico, led the study and told Science Daily that researchers have been saying for more than a century that drought was related to the civilization’s demise.

“Our results show rather modest rainfall reductions between times when the Classic Maya civilization flourished and its collapse between 800 to 950,” researcher Eelco Rohling, a paleoclimatologist at the University of Southampton in England, told LiveScience. “These reductions amount to only 25 to 40 percent in annual rainfall, but they were large enough for evaporation to become dominant over rainfall, and open water availability was rapidly reduced. The data suggest that the main cause was a decrease in summer storm activity.”

Having dry spells in the summer was the worst timing for the Mayans.

“Summer was the main season for cultivation and replenishment of Maya freshwater storage systems and there are no rivers in the Yucatan lowlands,” Rohling told LiveScience.

He explained that the ancient Maya had become dependent on the normal levels of rainfall. “Then, even a rather subtle climatic change was enough to create serious problems,” he told LiveScience. “Societal disruptions and abandonment of cities are likely consequences of critical water shortages, especially because there seems to have been a rapid repetition of multiyear droughts.”

Gerald Haug, a climate geologist of the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich, Switzerland, told ScienceMag.org that this study is a good addition to the evidence that climate change contributed to the decline of the Mayan civilization, but he says researchers should not ignore other factors like social and political developments.

The authors of this study also noted that the droughts that helped bring down the ancient Mayans are coming to the same region again, as predicted by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.

“There are differences too, but the warning is clear—what seems like a minor reduction in water availability may lead to important, long-lasting problems,” Medina-Elizalde told LiveScience. “This problem is not unique to the Yucatan Peninsula, but applies to all regions in similar settings where evaporation is high. Today, we have the benefit of awareness, and we should act accordingly.”

Read more @ Indian Country Today Media Network.comAboriginal Leaders Agree With TRC, Want Action - ICTMN.com.

August 8, 2012

Dams Are Potential Hidden Climate Change Instigator: Study

Filed under: Environment,News Alerts — Tags: , , , , — ICTMN Staff @ 7:25 pm

Dams have long been seen as a source of green energy. But the cost of providing that energy has not been studied, until now. And the jump in methane gas that happens during water-level changes has emerged as a potential factor in climate change with a new study.

Measuring gases dissolved in the water column of Lacamas Lake, Clark County, Washington State University–Vancouver doctoral student Bridget Deemer has found that when water levels were drawndown, methane emissions leapt up twentyfold, the university announced in a media release on August 8.

“Reservoirs have typically been looked at as a green energy source,” Deemer said in the statement. “But their role in greenhouse gas emissions has been overlooked.”

In addition, fellow student Maria Glavin sampled bubbles rising from the mud in the lake to find a 36-fold methane increase when the water levels were drawn down, the statement said.

Methane is one of the infamous greenhouse gases that trap heat in the atmosphere. It is 25 times more efficient at doing so than carbon dioxide, another greenhouse gas, the release noted. This means that dams and the water they hold back can produce effects much stronger than the relatively small proportion of space they occupy on the planet, the university said.

There are 80,000 dams in the U.S. alone, the university said, quoting the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers National Inventory of Dams.

John Harrison, an assistant professor of earth and environmental sciences and the two students’ adviser, said this could lead to alterations in the way water drawdowns are managed. Deemer will soon examine three reservoirs in Oregon and the Klamath basin of northern California.

Many in Indian country advocate for dam removal entirely, which restores spawning runs for salmon and other species. Such removal is under way on the Penobscot River and in the works elsewhere.

Read more @ Indian Country Today Media Network.comWater Level Changes From Dams Release Climate-Changing Methane: Study - ICTMN.com.

August 10, 2012

Drought’s Opposite: Santa Clara Pueblo Fears Rain

Filed under: Environment,News Alerts,Politics — Tags: , , , , — Alysa Landry @ 12:00 pm

New Mexico’s Santa Clara Pueblo fears further damage to their village of 3,100 people in the aftermath of last year’s Las Conchas wildfire as seasonal rains send water and debris down the canyon.

One year ago, what was then the largest wildfire in New Mexico history devastated the Pueblo, burning nearly 157,000 acres. This year, the Pueblo seek volunteers to help fill sandbags to stave off flooding from Santa Clara Canyon.

The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) awarded $11 million in federal funds to help the Pueblo recover. The grant will go toward removing sediment from ponds inside Santa Clara Pueblo, U.S. Sen. Tom Udall said July 31 during his weekly radio address. He toured Santa Clara Pueblo just after floods washed away soil and exposed gas lines in July.

“The Pueblo have done their best to deal with these extreme weather events,” Udall said. “The Pueblo can finally start to clear the sediment that has washed down from the Las Conchas fire burn scar with every monsoon. These waters flowing down have ruined the ponds and funneled the rain down into the pueblo.”

New Mexico Governor Susana Martinez, after touring the pueblo on July 17, pledged another $63,000 in recovery funds. This comes in addition to hundreds of thousands of dollars that the village has spent from its own bank account to prevent additional damage to the canyon.

“It’s amazing what has happened in our canyon as a result of last year’s fire,” Santa Clara Governor Walter Dasheno said in a news release about Martinez’s visit. “At one point on the tour, Governor Martinez did admit that she did not realize how extensive the damage was in the canyon. I think this really opened up her eyes to the devastation and the amount of resources we need to clean things up.”

The Pueblo estimate that it will take millions of dollars and 10 years of restoration efforts to get the canyon back to its natural state. The canyon is home to numerous tribal cultural properties, but it also is the Pueblo’s church, Dasheno said.

“It’s where our culture tells us we come from,” he said. “We pray for rain and we want the rain to come, but we are cautious because too much could ultimately mean destruction for the canyon and the Santa Clara Village.”

The Las Conchas fire started on June 26, 2011. It burned 43,000 acres the first day, driven by a strong wind combined with dry conditions caused by a six-month drought. By the time it was under control in August, the fire had destroyed 63 homes and 49 other buildings.

But the fire was only part of the disaster. Wildfires create “hydrophobic soil,” Michael Chavarria, director of the Santa Clara Foresty Department, said in a statement. That means the damaged forest floor no longer absorbs moisture. When the rain falls, “it has nowhere to go but down,” he said, adding that it takes just 20 minutes to reach the village.

Thousands of cubic feet of silt and debris already have filled fishing ponds and the Santa Clara Creek. The ponds are the last lines of defense against flooding the village, Santa Clara said in a news release. The water also is unearthing infrastructure, like the gas line exposure that forced evacuation of the tribe’s government buildings in July and prompted the council to declare an emergency.

The Las Conchas fire left a burn scar of more than 156,000 acres, including nearly half of the 31,000-acre Santa Clara Canyon, said Stephen Scissons, a hydrology engineer with the Albuquerque office of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. The canyon is almost exclusively on tribal land, and it is home to many cultural and natural resources used by the Pueblo.

The most recent flood was July 11, Scissons said. About 1.25 inches of rain fell during a four-hour period, but water flowed from the canyon at 2,000 cubic feet per second.

“This is normal, everyday monsoon rain,” he said. “This is not rain that would normally cause a flood event.”

In the aftermath of a wildfire, hydrologists determine the burn severity and the slope of the land to gauge flood danger. Of the Santa Clara land that was damaged in the Las Conchas fire, 77 percent suffered moderate to severe burns, Scissons said. Much of the burn also occurred near the steepest part of the canyon, which further increases flood danger.

The canyon already was a high risk for floods because of the Cerro Grande fire, which ripped through the area in 2000, destroying much of the vegetation.

“That was 12 years ago, but there was still some healing going on from that fire,” Scissons said. “Then it was hit again.”

Depending on rainfall and other factors, land scarred by wildfire can take between five and 15 years to heal, Scissons said.

Although the fire was extinguished more than a year ago, recovery has just begun, Dasheno said.

“What we’re doing is regrouping,” he said. “We need to see where the issues are and who is out there taking proactive measures. What makes our situation unique is that we’re next to the canyon, and the fire burned most of the vegetation. So every time it rains, we have the potential of getting flooded. Our concern at this point is that there’s little to nothing to hold back flood waters. We’re looking for all the measures we can to hold it back.”

The Army Corps of Engineers last year donated sand bags to the Pueblo, along with training and assistance in placing the bags to best prevent flooding. The same scenario is playing out again this year, Scissons said. It likely will continue until the land has recovered some of its natural vegetation, but drought conditions are expected to increase the recovery period.

“We all want it to rain in the Southwest, but there are some places we don’t want it to rain at all,” he said. “It’s a catch-22. We need the rain to help the watershed, for the vegetation to come back, but we don’t want the flooding.”

Dasheno is asking residents to stay put.

“We don’t want people to leave their residences,” he said. “We will find every measure to protect homes, livelihoods and property.”

Read more @ Indian Country Today Media Network.comNASA's 'Mohawk Guy' and 18 Other Famous Hairstyle Appropriators - ICTMN.com.

October 23, 2012

Elections 2012: A Debate About Power, But Not About Mother Earth

Ninety minutes are too quick for a debate about the world. In fact the globe shrunk to a few regions and a few issues in the final debate between President Barack Obama and Republican challenger Mitt Romney.

There was a lot of discussion about the Middle East, and the threat of new war, Pakistan and a bit about China, and the role of America in the world.

“America’s going to come back,” Romney said his closing statement. “This nation is the hope of the earth.”

Romney’s hope of the earth can be boiled down to a single idea, power. American power, strength, is the key to global stability.

“Our purpose is to make sure the world is more, is peaceful,” Romney said. “We want a peaceful planet. We want people to be able to enjoy their lives and know they’re going to have a bright and prosperous future, not be at war. That’s our purpose. And the mantle of leadership for the — promoting the principles of peace has fallen to America. We didn’t ask for it. But it’s an honor that we have it.”

However Obama said America “has to stand with democracy.” Even when uncomfortable such as uprisings during the Arab Spring. “What I’ve also said is that now that you have a democratically elected government in Egypt, that they have to make sure that they take responsibility for protecting religious minorities. And we have put significant pressure on them to make sure they’re doing that; to recognize the rights of women, which is critical throughout the region. These countries can’t develop if young women are not given the kind of education that they need.”

Obama was prepared for this debate. He challenged Romney, often, on facts and narrative. He was quick to interject when Romney’s positions had changed (such as setting a withdrawal date for U.S. troops from Afghanistan.) And, both men would be tougher, albeit, in different ways on the economic relationship with China.

The night’s sharpest exchange focused on the Navy. “Our Navy is old, excuse me, our Navy is smaller now than at any time since 1917,” Romney said. “That’s unacceptable to me.”

Obama seemed ready for the exact date and countered quickly.

“You mentioned the Navy, for example, and that we have fewer ships than we did in 1916,” Obama said. “Well, Governor, we also have fewer horses and bayonets, because the nature of our military’s changed. We have these things called aircraft carriers, where planes land on them. We have these ships that go underwater, nuclear submarines.”

Ships that go under water? In two words the president dismissed Romney’s international policies as out of date.

There was a lot more said about the military (Romney says we spend too little, Obama says it’s about right) that consumes nearly half of all global spending. About Israel (both said a great ally). About Pakistan. (Encouraging stability.)

On Twitter, Indian Country Today Media Network readers were on the case. To this day we don’t know if Romney will support the best science in coming up with a strategy. Except that in this debate, in every debate, and on the campaign trail, Romney says how much he wants the Keystone XL pipeline and professes his love for coal.

Or, as @TheresaBraine put it on Twitter: “Amazes me how they miss the point that all this will be moot if we make our habitat uninhabitable.”

Once again the ICTMN audience was significant on Twitter during the debate. On a night with a lot going on – baseball playoffs and a Monday Night Football game – more than 211,000 accounts were reached. There was a good, smart conversation about how these issues impact Indian country.

Throughout the night, for example, Twitter participants wanted more information about how veterans fit into this discussion. @J_Opal wrote: “Finally…VETERANS! #mydadisavet” And, @WiteSpider added, “Making sure our vets r getting help they need when it comes 2 post traumatic stress syndrome. That’s what I’ve waiting for.”

But let’s consider a moment about what was not said. As Romney said, America as the “hope of the earth.”

A hope of the earth implies that there are issues beyond power politics. One such issue was missing from the debate: Climate change was not on the agenda.

Think about place. The very moment when climate change is the greatest challenge is the same moment when the government lacks the resources to pay for solutions. Over the next forty years, the International Organization for Migration estimates that 200 million to 1 billion people will have to move because their land will be under water or in permanent drought. Native communities both in the United States and globally will be among the first affected, forced to move.

But the final debate didn’t explore that challenge, except to hear more about how coal and other natural resource development will create jobs.

However in his closing statement, Obama did say this: “We’ve got to do some nation building here at home.”

An understatement in a night of powerful talk.

Mark Trahant is a writer, speaker and Twitter poet. He is a member of the Shoshone-Bannock Tribes and lives in Fort Hall, Idaho. He has been writing about Indian Country for more than three decades. His e-mail is: marktrahant@thecedarsgroup.org.

Read more @ Indian Country Today Media Network.comElections 2012: A Debate About Power, But Not About Mother Earth - ICTMN.com.
Older Posts »
Blog powered by Wordpress